Fraud in trade finance is rarely as straightforward as it sounds.

For trade credit insurers and surety providers, the fraudster is often not targeting the insurer at all. Yet when a transaction or financing structure collapses, the insurer can still be left carrying the loss.

That is one of the key findings of ICISA’s new working paper, “Fraud” – Not That Simple: Understanding Fraud Patterns in Trade Finance, Credit Insurance and Surety.

The paper examines five recent cases across fuel distribution, automotive financing, supply chain finance, receivables finance and commodity trading. While the mechanisms differ, a common pattern emerges: the real risk was often hidden beneath a transaction that appeared sound on paper.

Clean financial statements and strong ratings did not necessarily reveal the underlying problems. Instead, the cases involved issues such as fabricated or disputed receivables, off-balance-sheet financing, complex financing structures, unusual trading terms and transactions that existed more convincingly on paper than in economic reality.

Looking beyond the balance sheet

The cases raise an important question for underwriters: is traditional credit analysis enough?

The answer increasingly appears to be no.

Understanding the financial strength of an obligor remains essential, but it may not be enough when insurance is supporting complex financing or commodity transactions. Underwriters also need to understand the underlying trade, the parties involved, the flow of goods and money, and why the transaction makes commercial sense.

Complexity itself is not evidence of fraud. But the more layers a transaction contains, the harder it can become to see what is really happening underneath.

Fraud prevention starts before the claim

The paper’s message is therefore not simply about detecting fraud. It is about recognising fraud risk earlier.

That means stronger sector expertise, greater scrutiny of financing structures, understanding related-party relationships, monitoring unusual growth and trading terms, and maintaining visibility over the underlying transaction.

It also means recognising that fraud risk is not solely a claims issue. By the time a claim arrives, many opportunities to prevent or contain the loss may already have disappeared.

Fraud may not always look like fraud. Sometimes it looks like growth, liquidity, a strong rating—or simply a complicated transaction.

ICISA’s new paper explores these patterns through five real-world cases and draws out practical lessons for underwriting, policy wording, risk monitoring, claims and recovery.